Reviews

“My husband and I absolutely love this place. The service is always exceptional and the chef is amazing.  From first course through dessert, everything was spectacular.”

“JeanneR” Open Table 4/10/2023

“Everything was delicious. Claire is a great waitperson. The restaurant is lovely, A real treat.”

“RalphF” Open Table 4/11/2023

“Even though it was busy we did not feel rushed at all. This is a restaurant that we can always count on impressing guests and getting a nice meal. Well done yet again 5th Season!”

“Kate Vet” Google Review 4/13/2023

“This is our favorite restaurant on Long Island. Never disappoints.”

“ChristopherR” Open Table 4/15/2023

“Service was a 5 out of 5. Jason and Ida were great. Food was a 5 out of 5. Atmosphere was also a 5. Will definitely be back next trip to Jeff.”

“Rey” Google Review 4/8/2023

“Love this place! Great food & wonderful service.  If farm to table is your thing, then you will love this restaurant!”

“Christine” on Yelp 4/6/2023

“Great pre-fix menu choices. This is the second time eating here. Food is amazing! Portion size is perfect.”

“LauDre” Open Table 3/28/2023

“This is one of our favorite restaurants. We are never disappointed.”

“Fran” Open Table 3/26/2023

“I’ve never had anything that wasn’t absolutely outstanding. Their service is never less than wonderful.”

“Caity” on Yelp 1/27/2023

“Wonderful dining experience; well-paced, professional, smart menu.  Top notch service and the duck was phenomenal!  I’ll be back soon!”

“Chris G.” on Yelp 12/28/2022

“I’m a tough critic when it comes to giving out five stars, however, this was a five-star experience. Our server was absolutely incredible. She knew every order and was attentive to our needs without being overbearing. The food was first class without being overpriced. I enjoyed a good atmosphere with good friends. I recommend the fifth season for anybody looking to enjoy a classy night out.”

“J.W.” Google Review 3/16/2023

“I had a few professional events at the Fifth Season and the food was great. I decided to have my daughter’s communion party there and it did not disappoint. Great food and great service. Highly recommend this place.”

“Joseph” on Trip Advisor 5/25/2022

“I hosted our daughter’s bridal shower here. Everything was wonderful! Deborah, the Event Coordinator was beyond helpful. Our family were in the midst of some tough times and Deborah was extra patient and helpful to make the planning process as easy as possible and our daughter’s day special. Jason was our waiter and could not possibly have done a better job. He was personable, friendly, always helpful, thoughtful, and fun. Both Deborah & Jason were both professional and conscientious about every aspect of the shower and how to make it easier on us. God bless you both!! The food was delicious, as well. They were SO flexible – my daughter has celiac (so GF), a vegetarian and a vegan guest, two youngsters who needed kids’ menus, etc. The staff never batted an eyelash. Everything was perfect! Thank you immensely for helping to make our daughter’s shower all we could have hoped for!! We highly recommend this restaurant!!”

“GisgGirl” on Trip Advisor 5/15/2022

“We enjoyed The Fifth Season. The food is great and nicely presented, They provide a nice mix of options with meat dishes (the duck is great) and vegetarian dishes. The staff is friendly and knows the menu. Worth giving it a try if you’re looking for something new.”

“Brian” on Google 2/10/2023

“Excellent as always. The app special of chicken/feta strudel with a yogurt/harissa sauce was amazing. The monk fish was cooked to perfection. I love the fact that when I sit down I can completely trust every aspect of my meal and service. Top notch.”

Open Table Diner 3/18/2023

“Good service, tasty food, nice décor, that’s about it!”

“JohnA” Open Table 3/17/2023

“First time dining here and it was fantastic. The food was simply amazing. The place was incredibly busy but the wait staff were still attentive and timely. I would recommend eating here without any hesitation.”

Open Table Diner 3/11/2023

“We had an amazing time at The Fifth Season. It was a cold and rainy night but the restaurant was warm and inviting. Loved our short rib and gnocchi w/salmon meals. Cocktails were delicious. The service was awesome and everyone was so nice. Can’t wait to go back soon.”

“Angela” Open Table 3/10/2023

“My husband and I come here for most special occasions. Recently we went here for our anniversary. The food was amazing, the wait staff was phenomenal, and it’s absolutely beautiful with Christmas decorations. They wrote happy anniversary on our desserts and had rose petals on the table to make it a memorable dinner.”

“Amanda” on Google 12/20/2022

“Ah-mazing food, local ingredients, super delicious!  Celebrated my birthday with family. Lovely dessert celebration. Lovely view, too. Must go back. PS- loved that I have Gluten Free & Dairy Free options”

“Madelyn” on Google 10/6/2022